Should execution of the severely mentally ill or retarded.

Third many mentally ill offenders who are sentenced to death are so impaired that at the time of execution they cannot emotionally appreciate the significance of their punishment and cannot be executed under the eighth amendment; also given the unethical and medically inappropriate role in which such treatment cast mental health professionals. Lastly, prior to a person being put to death, many.

There are significant gaps in the legal protection accorded severely mentally ill defendants charged with or convicted of a capital crime. Most notably, this country still permits the execution of the severely mentally ill. The problem is not a small one. A leading mental health group, Mental Health America, estimates that five to ten percent of all death row inmates suffer.

Does the death penalty target people who are mentally ill.

A mentally ill death row inmate can only be executed if he or she is restored to competency (sanity) and understands the above. Restoration may be accomplished through a variety of means that normally would include medication in addition to therapy. A death row inmate who takes antipsychotic medication voluntarily presents no constitutional issues. The problem is with those inmates who refuse.The issue of those who are mentally ill being criminalized is one of the factors most studies have failed to take into account. There is a tendency in society to arrest the mentally ill for an offense where a person who was not mentally ill might not have been arrested. Another issue is that of deviance being classified medically. In this.The Death Penalty and Mental Illness Receiving the death penalty is the worst and final penalty that the United States Justice System can administer, especially for those who are mentally ill. Many Americans are questioning the morality of executing mentally ill convicts, as well as the validity of the death penalty itself. These are the questions Americans should be asking, or at least.


Because we feared the mentally ill, they were considered to be outcasts of society. Some were even executed as witches in the early days of our country. (Micah Steele, 2009). It was believed that the mentally ill were possessed by demons or witches. The mentally ill were shunned, banished, or locked away because they were feared. Because people.Families of murder victims would benefit far more if the funds now being used for the costly process of executions were diverted to counseling and other assistance. (Baldus, David. 2008) Mentally ill people are executed, one out of every ten who has been executed in the United States since 1977 is mentally ill, according to Amnesty International and the National Association on Mental Illness.

For a while the mentally ill were thought of as being just a little different, the severity of their illness was not being recognized. Now that there are several advances in science, medicine, and the human body, mental illness is a little more understood. Many people no longer dismiss the mentally ill and realize that the mentally ill really do have serious issues that need to be addressed.

Read More

Thus, it appears that the protection for the mentally retarded may be improving; only 34 mentally ill people have been executed over the past 25 years, and the level of proof required for legal insanity seems to be decreasing. Therefore, although, the safeguard has not effectively prevented the insane from being executed, it may be influencing future policies in this area, and Penry’s case.

Read More

Meanwhile, mentally ill and impoverished murderers who could not afford good lawyers and did not receive much media attention were given the death penalty. In Alabama, David Hocker was executed after a one-day trial as his mental illness was not sufficiently described to the jury. Alabama also executed a 74-year-old man who had been on death row for 27 years and was beset by medical problems.

Read More

The US Supreme Court first addressed the question of whether the Constitution allows the mentally ill to be executed in 1986, in the case of Ford v Wainwright (4). The court found it unconstitutional, although it could not agree on a single rationale for that decision, citing variously concerns about inhumane treatment and the lack of either deterrent effect or retributive value of such action.

Read More

This instability causes the mentally to go crazy and take everything out on the nearest guardian they see and the mentally insane should not be penalized for being put into a state of craziness. The mentally insane receiving the death penalty is an abomination. All abominations have similar characteristics. Like crime in the United States, inflicting the death penalty on the mentally insane is.

Read More

As I have already Argumentative Essay Executing Mentally Ill had some bad experiences with Argumentative Essay Executing Mentally Ill writing services, I asked 6DollarEssay.com to provide me with a draft of the work. They obliged and provided me with adraft of the work which I must say was a great piece of writing that impressed my professor as well. The final work when submitted got me A.

Read More

The problem of being mentally ill and homeless is also a social problem because the problem of mental illness and homelessness in the United States affects thousands of people. There are several national estimates of homelessness. In a recent approximation USA Today estimated 1.6 million people used transitional housing or emergency shelters. Another approximation is from a study done by the.

Read More

Blake 2 anxiety to bipolar disorders and Schizophrenia” (Rehab Needs all Addicts pg.1). With this medication being available to prisoners through the prison system it makes the mentally disabled’s transition much smoother. It even makes the prison environment safer for guards, other prisoners, and the guest that come to visit their family who are being executed.

Read More

Mental Health Treatment in the Past. For much of history, the mentally ill have been treated very poorly. It was believed that mental illness was caused by demonic possession, witchcraft, or an angry god (Szasz, 1960). For example, in medieval times, abnormal behaviors were viewed as a sign that a person was possessed by demons. If someone was.

Read More

Mentally Disabled Shouldn't Receive Death Penalty, Says UF Professor. December 5, 2000. GAINESVILLE, Fla. — Defendants with mental disabilities should not be sentenced to death, a practice 38 states still allow, according to a University of Florida professor of law and psychiatry. In an article published in the California Law Review, Christopher Slobogin, a professor in the Fredric G. Levin.

Read More